Milwaukee

904 E. Center St., Milwaukee WI

Noon – 4pm

Cedarburg

Inside Fermentorium · 7481 WI-60 Trunk, Cedarburg WI

Noon – 4pm

What time do you open on Record Store Day?

Both locations open at noon (12pm). We do not open early — no exceptions. No amount of texting or calling will change this. Plan accordingly.

Do you have [specific title] in stock?

We can't confirm individual titles in advance. A few days before RSD, we post videos on Instagram showing exactly what arrived in our order — that's the closest thing to a confirmed list. Follow us: @we_buy_records

Can I reserve or hold a title ahead of time?

No. No holds, no reservations, no custom orders, no call-aheads. Everything is first come, first served at both locations. This is how RSD works — we can't make exceptions.

How many copies of a title can I buy?

One copy per title, per person. This is an official Record Store Day rule — not a store policy we can override. There is no limit on how many different titles you can buy, just one copy of each.

Do you carry the full RSD release list?

No store carries everything. We order a wide variety of titles — some we'll have in multiples, some will be single copies. Check our Instagram a few days out for the preview.

How long is the line usually?

We typically have a line, but it's consistently smaller and faster-moving than most stores. You won't be camping out for hours. Show up around 11:30-11:45 and you'll be in good shape.

Can I buy RSD titles online or by phone?

No. RSD titles are in-person only at both locations. No website orders, no phone orders, no Instagram DM orders.

What payment do you accept?

Cash and credit/debit cards at both locations.

Where exactly is the Cedarburg location?

Inside the Fermentorium Brewery — 7481 WI-60 Trunk, Cedarburg, WI 53012. Walk in, find us inside. Same hours: noon to 4pm.