Sell Vinyl Records in Wisconsin for Cash — Local Buyers, Honest Offers

Looking for where to sell vinyl records in Wisconsin? We Buy Records Milwaukee offers fast, local cash offers for LPs, 45s, and entire record collections anywhere in the state — including Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Racine, Kenosha, and beyond. Skip the online hassle — no listings, no shipping, no returns. Deal directly with trusted Wisconsin vinyl buyers who know the real value of your records, from classic rock and soul to rare jazz and modern reissues.

Serving all of Wisconsin — fair prices, same-day pickup, and no appraisal fees.

Areas We Serve in Wisconsin

Tap your city to learn more or call/text (414) 232-7606.

Why Sell Your Records to We Buy Records Milwaukee

Selling locally is faster, safer, and more profitable than listing on eBay or Facebook Marketplace. When you sell to We Buy Records Milwaukee, you:

• Skip grading, photography, shipping, and messaging
• Get immediate cash offers from experienced buyers
• Avoid platform fees, returns, and scams
• Declutter without lifting heavy boxes

Online selling takes expert knowledge—pressing ID, condition grading, packing, and customer service. We handle it all. Andy and the team make fair, upfront offers and even haul away your records the same day.

What We’re Looking For

We buy vinyl LPs (12") and 45s (7") across most genres: Soul, Funk, Rock, Jazz, Gospel, Rap, Disco, Folk, World, Punk, Metal, Indie, Avant Garde, and select Soundtracks.

We also consider cassettes, CDs, and stereo gear (turntables, receivers, speakers) — but we’re selective. Read what we can and can’t consider →

What We’re Not Looking For

Please note — we do not buy 78s or the following categories: Edison discs, Christmas, Children’s, Big Band, Broadway, Country, most Classical, Crooner (Sinatra, etc.), Easy Listening (Mantovani, 101 Strings, Mancini), or Polka.