Trusted local record buyers serving Milwaukee & SE Wisconsin since 1999 - Hundreds of Five Star Reviews From Sellers
Fast, simple, honest, and friendly :) We’ve earned an A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau for our fair offers.
Housecalls made for large collections (300/400 or more records in our desired styles - rock, jazz, r&b)
Looking for where to sell your vinyl records or who buys old records near you? We make it easy to sell LPs, 45s, and full album collections for cash in Milwaukee. Whether you’re downsizing, cleaning out the basement, or parting with a loved one’s collection, we offer honest prices, fast service, and house calls.
Owner Andy Noble is a lifelong record collector and DJ who buys records in Milwaukee and all over SE Wisconsin. Big Collection? We Make House Calls!
"I had the pleasure of meeting Andy Noble who came to my house and purchased my small album collection. It was hard parting with the fond memories, but Andy offered me a very reasonable price that I could not refuse. It felt good knowing that my albums would be offered for sale to vinyl enthusiasts."
— Nell Flower (5 Star Google Review)
Read more reviews from actual record sellers for Andy and We Buy Records Milwaukee here!
We also buy certain tapes, CDs and stereo equipment.
“A pleasurable experience, Andy set up a time to come to our home to view what we had and showed up when he said he would. The whole process was very smooth, and we even learned a few things, it was a pleasure speaking with him. Made a perfect offer for what we had and completed a sale immediately. Very glad that the items will be enjoyed by others.”
Whether you’ve just lost a loved one, you’re moving to a smaller place, or you need cash from a valuable collection—we’ve helped thousands of people through this exact moment with respect, speed, and fair offers.
Sorting through a loved one’s record collection can feel overwhelming. We handle everything gently—from first call to pickup—so you can focus on what matters.
Headed to a smaller place? We make it simple to lighten the load and get a fair offer—often with same-week pickup across Milwaukee and nearby counties.
From rare soul 45s to audiophile LPs—if your collection has serious value, we’ll evaluate quickly and pay competitively. No piecemeal selling required.
Located at 904 E. Center St, Milwaukee. Open daily, 12–4 PM. We buy LPs, 45s, CDs, tapes, and vintage stereo gear.
Get a personal response from Andy same day, usually within an hour!
Selling your used album collection locally is faster, easier, and more profitable than dealing with eBay or Facebook Marketplace.
What You’ll Gain:
Save time and effort – No more grading records or identifying pressings.
Get a fair price – We offer cash upfront.
Avoid fees and scams – No online transaction headaches.
Declutter hassle-free – We even handle heavy lifting!
Selling online means managing listings, dealing with returns, and risking scams. At We Buy Records, our expert team handles everything—from condition grading to transporting your collection. Let us do the hard work so you don’t have to!
What We’re Looking For
Vinyl LPs (12") & 45s (7")
Good condition Soul, Rock, Jazz, Gospel, Rap, Disco, World, Funk, Folk, Avant Garde, Punk, Metal, Indie, and some Soundtracks.
Cassettes, CDs & Stereo Gear
We buy select tapes, CDs, and gear (turntables, receivers, speakers). We’re picky—learn more about what we accept HERE
We buy many types of records, including classic rock and jazz.
Have a super rare $500+ record and out of state from us (Wisconsin)? Contact us today, we often buy $500-$10k records by mail. Click here for more info on how to sell rare records!
No 78s (Victrola records), Edison records
No Holiday, Children’s, or Big Band
No Broadway, Country, Classical, Opera, or Crooner
No Easy Listening (Mantovani, Sinatra, etc.) or Polka
Beat up or water damaged records
Check this page for a free record selling guide!
Click here to try out our cool new vinyl record collection appraisal tool!
To Sell Records Near Me Call or Text Andy 414-232-7606 Or Fill Out The Form At The Bottom Of This Page! Here is a short video on some basic information we’ll ask about your records
How To Sell A Vinyl Record Collection
We’re proud to be one of the highest-rated Milwaukee record stores that buy vinyl—from classic rock LPs to soul 45s, we pay top dollar for the records you’re no longer spinning.
Want to buy a turntable or vinyl accessories?
Checkout the gear we have tested and loved!
We are starting a DJ School - Milwaukee DJ Academy - starting summer 2024! Learn how to mix on vinyl, CDJ and controller!
You can bring vinyl records in to sell 7 days a week from 12-4PM
Our store location:
WE BUY RECORDS
904 E Center St,
Milwaukee, WI 53212
“I had the pleasure of meeting Andy Noble who came to my house and purchased my small record collection. It was hard parting with the fond memories, but Andy offered me a very reasonable price that I could not refuse. It felt good knowing that my albums would be offered for sale to vinyl enthusiasts.”
If you have a large collection (300+ records) of records we can make a house call!
Andy and the We Buy Records Milwaukee crew buy records 24/7/365! Call today to get started!
We Buy Records Milwaukee
Milwaukee’s vinyl specialists
Have old receivers, turntables, and speakers? We buy these, too! Check out our page here and find out the easiest way to turn your old stereo gear into cash!
We do! We’re based in Milwaukee and buy LPs, 45s, and full vinyl collections for cash across Southeastern Wisconsin.
Right here. Just call or text us for a fast quote. We offer house calls, drop-offs, and generous cash payouts for quality records.
We buy a wide range of genres including classic rock, soul, jazz, funk, punk, hip-hop, reggae, blues, and more. Both LPs and 45s are welcome.
Yes! Whether you’re downsizing, settling an estate, or selling a lifelong collection, we specialize in large batches and handle everything with care.
You can—but selling locally is usually faster, safer, and more profitable. We make the process simple with no grading, listing, or shipping needed.
We’re a Milwaukee-based buyer serving SE Wisconsin. Skip the hassle of selling online—get a fair, cash offer locally for your records today.
It depends on the artist, condition, pressing, and demand. We’re happy to take a look and let you know what’s valuable in your collection.
We do—and we pay fairly. If you're looking for a fast, local sale with cash in hand, we make it easy to sell your records in Milwaukee and surrounding areas.
Yes, we buy vinyl locally across SE Wisconsin. Whether you’re in Milwaukee, Wauwatosa, or the suburbs, we’re happy to make house calls or schedule pickups for serious collections.
Our Milwaukee shop is one of the best places to sell old records for cash. We’re known for fair pricing, fast service, and treating your collection with respect.
